the tone trap most food brands fall into

October 7, 2026
 · 

Where people, culture, and food collide.

Every food brand feels the pressure right now: get louder, get weirder, get on the trend before someone else does. 

So brands overcorrect. They bolt on internet humor that has nothing to do with who they actually are, or they play it so safe they disappear entirely.

Neither extreme is the goal. The brands that actually win aren't the loudest or the most buttoned-up. They're the ones who know exactly who they're talking to, and say it like they mean it.

Trader Joe's plays, but never performs

Trader Joe's runs no TV ads, no billboards, no X clapbacks. 

What it does have is the Fearless Flyer, a newsletter written like a well-traveled friend who shops smart and shares tips generously. Product names lean playful (Cowboy Caviar, Everything But the Bagel Seasoning), but the voice never tips into trying too hard. 

It stays friendly, curious, lightly witty, and always clear.

The insight: playful doesn't mean performative. Trader Joe's knows its audience wants discovery and honesty, not a brand doing bits at them. The tone fits the customer, not a trend cycle.

Chick-fil-A is warm on purpose, not cautious by default

Chick-fil-A's social voice is famously polite, but polite isn't the same as boring. 

It tells jokes. It teases. It's just never mean-spirited about it. The brand sounds like it's smiling while it talks, because that's exactly who its audience expects it to be.

The insight: "safe" gets confused with "restrained." Chick-fil-A isn't holding back, it's just calibrated. The tone is warm because the audience is, not because the brand is afraid to have a personality.

Rao's proved premium doesn't have to be loud

Rao's built a billion-dollar sauce business without chasing a viral moment. A Worth magazine profile described the brand simply as: “warm, confident, and slightly out of reach.”

Sales have grown more than 450% over seven years, largely by staying exactly what it's always been: a jar with restaurant-quality heritage behind it, instead of stretching for relevance it doesn't need.

The insight: confidence isn't the same as edge. Rao's didn't need a meme or a stunt to matter. It just had to sound like it actually believed in the product, and let that carry the tone.

The through-line

Trader Joe's, Chick-fil-A, and Rao's are nowhere near the same brand voice: playful, warm, confident, but none of them are chasing edge or hiding behind safe. 

They picked a tone that actually matches who's buying, and they committed to it everywhere. 

That's the whole job: not louder, not safer, just right.

Ready to find the tone that's actually yours?

Tagged: enews

RMD The Food Agency HQ
2099 West 5th Avenue
Columbus, OH 43212

FOLLOW US

Instagram

FOLLOW US

Linkedin
Sandwich-and-soda-icon
Rmd-logo-blue-no-tag

© Rmd Advertising Inc.